|Two of a Kind|
|Season 3, Episode 1|
|Take Your Time||Red Hood|
SAME COIN- When Harvey Dent is seemingly cured, and given surgery to correct his disfigurement, he readily resumes his life as DA of Gotham. Madeline McCarthy, Marilyn's unstable twin sister, breaks out of Arkham and tempts him back to his criminal ways. Elsewhere, Stephanie Brown seeks counsel concerning her recent actions. As Talia's due date draws nearer, Nyssa al Ghul helps her form a strategy against the League with or without the aid of a still-hesitant Bruce Wayne.
- Luke Evans as Bruce Wayne/Batman
- Aaron Paul as Jason Todd (credit only)
- Rose McIver as Stephanie Brown/Batgirl
- Andrew Scott as Harvey Dent/Two-Face
- Katrina Law as Nyssa al Ghul
- Rachel Skarsten as Talia al Ghul (Earth 3)
- Crystal Reed as Sofia Falcone
- Diogo Morgado as Bane (credit only)
- Jane Levy as Barbara Gordon (credit only)
- Jessica Stroup as Marilyn McCarthy & Madeline McCarthy
- Oded Fehr as Ra's al Ghul (credit only)
- Katie Cassidy as Laurel Lance
- Jessica de Gouw as Helena Bertinelli
- Katie McGrath as Lena Luthor
- Floriana Lima as Maggie Danvers (credit only)
- with John Barrowman as Malcolm Merlyn (credit only)
- and Bryan Cranston as Commissioner James Gordon
- Antagonist: Madeline McCarthy
- This episode is Harvey-centric.
- Jason, Bane, Barbara, Ra's, Maggie, and Malcolm do not appear in this episode.
- This episode is inspired by the Batman: Black and White story of the same name, but it will have a happier ending.
- This is the 2nd and final episode of the series in which main characters are absent.
- This episode takes place on May 23, 2020.